Welcome to Doris Gallery

Blog 4
Transition Design Framework

Carnegie Mellon University. (n.d.). The Transition Design Framework [Diagram]. https://transitiondesignseminarcmu.net/the-transition-design-framework/
The concept of Transition Design was proposed by CMU (Carnegie Mellon University) in 2015; it focuses on the transition of a design-driven society to a more sustainable future (Social Design Sydney, 2017). People must deal with many "wicked" issues in twenty-first-century society: "climate change, forced migration, political and social polarization, global pandemics, lack of access to affordable housing/healthcare/education and many others (Carnegie Mellon University, 2015). The idea of transition is the key contemporary discussion – It is concerned with "how change is represented in complex systems and can be catalyzed and directed" (Carnegie Mellon University, 2015, p.2 ). What distinguishes transition design from other design frameworks is that it has a logical framework consisting of four areas of common development: 1. Visions for transition 2. Theories of change 3. Mindset and posture 4. New ways of designing.
-
A vision for transition
Visions of the future are open-ended and speculative, and their transition to a sustainable future must be ongoing. "Transition visioning is intended as a circular, iterative and error-friendly process (Carnegie Mellon University, 2015, para.5 )." It can be used to envision fresh ideas for the future, inspire action and provide hope for citizens.
2. Theories of change
The theory of change is a set of theories that explain the dynamics of change within complex systems. It is important because asking questions requires a deep understanding of the dynamics of change in complex social and natural systems (Carnegie Mellon University, 2015). Through a deeper understanding of society, designers can gain a more open-minded inspiration to raise social issues.
3. Posture and Mindset
To carry out this work, people must remain open, cooperative and self-reflective (Carnegie Mellon University, 2015). Fundamental changes in people usually occur through life experiences or cultural and religious teachings that lead to a shift in mindset and worldview. Our life experiences influence our viewpoints, how we assess complex issues, and how we approach problem-solving. Designers must utilize a good holistic thinking perspective and not just focus on one subjective view, which means collaboration is vital in transition design.
4. New ways of designing
For complex and challenging problems, transition designers need to learn how to see and solve them, because a single solution is not enough to solve complex problems; the solution must take ecological considerations into account. These solutions will lead, step by step, to a future created by shared sustainability.
In summary, transition design envisages a sustainable and desirable way of living, which means that transition design focuses on how to create a more desirable future in social, political and ecological development.
Strengths/Limitations
The advantage of the transition design is that it achieves this utopia by first imagining a vision of the future and then going back to the present and creating a 'transition pathway' to it. This method is called the "backcasting" approach and effectively solves complex societal issues.
Both speculative and transitional designs are used to solve 'complex problems. The difference between these two approaches is that transitional design has its own design framework. Speculative design projects are risky because when they anticipate a future vision, designers rarely consider whether the technology is feasible now or even in the future. However, the transitional design considers achievable goals as well as the long term.
Compared to the Transition Design, Pluriversal Design provides a lens through which to view the world from a place-based and grassroots perspective (Iwabuchi, 2021). In a pluralistic society, different communities respect each other so they can coexist comfortably and without conflict. In pluralistic design, designers can design and discuss together more effectively. On the other hand, Transition design does not point to this concept.
Case study




Studio Roosegaarde’s ultraviolet Urban Sun light “cleans public spaces of coronavirus.” (2021b, March 3). [Diagram]. Dezeen. https://www.dezeen.com/2021/03/03/urban-sun-daan-roosegaarde-safe-public-spaces-coronavirus/
A successful example of Transitional Design is Urban Sun, designed by Studio Roosegaarde. The Urban Sun device aims to make public gatherings possible by disinfecting against the Coronavirus with far ultraviolet light. According to Studio Roosegaarde, this light can be a safe disinfectant because of its shorter wavelength. While the vast majority of people are infected with Covid-19 indoors, it is possible to be infected outdoors. The chances of being infected with COVID-19 outdoors are significantly reduced because the specific light wavelength of 222nm from the urban sun disperses and dilutes the virus stream (Dezeen, 2021).
Urban sun uses the least energy possible to achieve the most significant possible effects. Despite the light being powered by electricity, its generation only requires a small amount of power—between 300 and 400 watts. According to Roosegaarde: “Throughout the design, we look at energy use and the materials we can use — from a design principle at default, we want to get maximum performance with minimum needs (Buckley, 2021, para. 14).” Therefore, this project sets an excellent example of energy saving and emission reduction, because it can be powered by solar panels or batteries that have been charged by solar panels (Buckley, 2021).
Compared to the other cases we analysed, this project is successful because it devised a solution to the COVID-19 that has occurred in recent years. During the Coronavirus, people feel anxious and even develop physical and mental health problems because most of the time, individuals are self-isolation at home and not able to travel free. In response to this problem, Studio Roosegaarde has designed the urban sun to kill the COVID-19 bacteria with a sustainable method and allow people to travel freely. It achieves the purpose of reducing the risk of infection and solving social problems while inspiring optimism for a better future where people can meet freely, bravely, and safely outside once more.
Reference
S. (2017, December 6). Transition Design. Social Design Sydney. https://socialdesignsydney.com/transition-design/
Iwabuchi, M. (2020, July 4). Emerging Design Attitudes: Speculative, Transitional, and Pluriversal Design. Medium. https://uxplanet.org/design-attitudes-for-this-century-speculative-transitional-and-pluriversal-design-fb55c9d401e6
Studio Roosegaarde’s ultraviolet Urban Sun light “cleans public spaces of coronavirus.” (2021, March 3). Dezeen. https://www.dezeen.com/2021/03/03/urban-sun-daan-roosegaarde-safe-public-spaces-coronavirus/
Buckley, S. (2021, July 12). The Urban Sun: A Light at the End of the COVID Tunnel? Sustainable Brands. https://sustainablebrands.com/read/product-service-design-innovation/the-urban-sun-a-light-at-the-end-of-the-covid-tunnel
Carnegie Mellon University. (n.d.). The Transition Design Framework [Diagram]. https://transitiondesignseminarcmu.net/the-transition-design-framework/
Studio Roosegaarde’s ultraviolet Urban Sun light “cleans public spaces of coronavirus.” (2021b, March 3). [Diagram]. Dezeen. https://www.dezeen.com/2021/03/03/urban-sun-daan-roosegaarde-safe-public-spaces-coronavirus/